Peanut Butter Recipes

Browse all Peanut Butter recipes from Randy Makes Candy.

Category All Caramel Chocolate Citrus Treats Copycats Fudge Holidays Keto Molded Candies No Chocolate Peanut Butter Randy's Favorites Truffles
Caramel

Snickers

A near-perfect re-creation of this classic treat. Chocolate, caramel, peanuts and peanut butter nougat – who can resist it?

Get the recipe →
Chocolate

5th Avenue Bars

If you’ve never had a 5th Avenue Bar, they’re kind of like Butterfingers – but maybe better.

Get the recipe →
Chocolate

Halloween Peanut Butter Truffles

Spooky Halloween Treats!
Eyeballs and ghosts with a chewy peanut butter center.

Get the recipe →
Chocolate

Peanut Butter Cups

A happy joining of two delightful flavors.

Get the recipe →
Chocolate

Smetzels

What the heck is a Smetzel? It’s a S’more made with a pretzel!

Get the recipe →
Chocolate

Butterfingers

Now you can make candy that tastes (almost) exactly like Butterfingers using this quick and easy recipe.

Get the recipe →
1 … 4 5 6